You are reading a MIX Online Opinion. In which we speak our minds. Nishant Kothary Meet Nishant Arrow

Opinions

10Comment Retweet

Like It or Not

Nov 4, 2010 In Web Culture By Nishant Kothary

Hidden neatly beneath the seemingly superficial surface of the “like” button are some peculiar insights about humanity. And deeper below that—our next collective challenge

Many of us wouldn’t be caught dead listening to John Mayer’s music. There isn’t a shortage of reasons we supply for our scorn, but one that usually the tops the list is “Well, he’s a douchebag.” The charade of reasoning always traverses a similar path: “Oh, Mayer is such a talentless hack. He can barely play guitar. And, all those tattoos? What, they’re supposed to fool us into believing he’s the real thing? A complete poser, and yeah, I could care less for his music.” Similar is the public opinion about “arrogant” director M. Night Shyamalan, “pedophile” actor/director Woody Allen or “adulterer” ex-president William Clinton.

We like to think that what we like or dislike has been passed through our own internal, objective merit test. But the reality is that most of our preferences, especially the publicly disclosed ones, meander through completely subjective paths,often even unbeknownst to us,before they finally land in a place fairly disconnected from the aesthetics of the object itself.

Merit is but one very small criterion we use in determining what we endorse or reject; character, personality and our own agendas have always ranked much higher. Politics is a classic case in point—charisma and personality, not public policy-making experience and skills, win elections. It’s no coincidence that image consultancy is a flourishing business in politics.

Like on a Weimy Snout

Now bring Facebook or Twitter into this picture, and you’ve got the ultimate behavioral experiment playing out every day. The “like” button (or a retweet) is the new black—everyone wants one and Facebook has made it possible to attach one to just about anything leave your Weimaraner’s snout. And the interaction model of the like button is so intuitive that even my mother, who’s hardly familiar with the online subculture, was able to “like” a post by my wife announcing that our dog made a short appearance on the local news.

If you think about it, “liking” something isn’t so different from getting a tattoo in an exposed region of the body—it’s a complex signaling mechanism that, among other things, influences how your social network perceives you. We all do this—not necessarily via tattoos—and it’s perfectly natural. But signaling something about yourself is entirely different than posing as a credible critic of a certain type of music or movie genre. Unfortunately, there’s no way to tell one from the other. Therefore, today we’re all expert critics.

It’s tempting to blame this seemingly apocalyptic and frightening situation on, as Josh cleverly dubs it, “the human centipede that is social networking”. But before we get carried away, let’s consider for a second that none of this is apocalyptic or frightening—the only thing that’s changed is the lifespan of approval/disapproval. While in the past we only caught a fleeting glance of someone’s bias—may it be a hipster pimping a new indie band as one destined to save our generation from mindless music or a critic heralding the next big blockbuster—today we can hit rewind on our DVR or log in to a website to see bias at that very moment it happens.

Ironic Tattoo

Like most things, there is a silver lining to all of this. We’ve shifted paradigms. The world now exists in snapshots where we are able to see the outcome as well as the path that lead to it. Essentially, we get to rewrite history, at least for ourselves. Preposterous as this may sound, remember that most history is just one interpretation of a situation anyway, so having a readily available archive to reinterpret it is probably a good thing.

It seems as if our calling as a society is to be more critical consumers of, well, criticism. This new, connected, transparent existence may well overwhelm us to death, but it is also precisely what may finally transcend us to the next frontier—for it demands that we all become quicker, smarter and more balanced thinkers. Remember this the next time you read something on Yelp, Amazon or Rotten Tomatoes. Picture the reviewer. Imagine her context. Question her motives.

And certainly don’t refrain from discarding her verdict.

p.s. If you liked this, then you may like what I write at rainypixels.com.

Follow the Conversation

10 comments so far. You should leave one, too.

Me said on Nov 5, 2010

Like

Jon Kragh said on Nov 10, 2010

Fun article, I dig your writing style.

Charlie McHenry Charlie McHenry said on Nov 13, 2010

I tend to look at the "like" button from the other end, as I mine data to micro-target messaging. For marketers & statisticians, the "liking" something is part of a larger narrative; a key to making messaging more granular, more targeted, and thus, more effective and engaging. I am more interested in what my targets perceive themselves to be, than what they may be labeled by outside observers.

Rose Rose said on Nov 17, 2010

Well, #1, I think John Mayer is a very talented guitar player, possibly one of the greatest.... but I don''t listen to his music because #1 - He''s a jerk, and #2 - I''m tired of listening to his crooning love songs. BUT if you listen to any of his songs from his Where The Light Is, you will be blown away by the talent, fan of his music style/personality or not.

---

I like to think that a transparent existence will eventually lead to less judgement, because we will realize how flawed everybody is and that their facade of a perfect life/personality is fake... And learn to accept people the way they are - usually very (or at least slightly) messed up :P

Nishant Nishant said on Nov 17, 2010

@Charlie—I can relate to that since I do that as a part of my job as well. Not only is the data useful, but the process of watching people liking publicly is often very entertaining.

@Rose—Yep, he''s definitely up there among my favorite guitar players. He keeps SRV alive. Nodding profusely to everything else you said as well. :-)

Garry DC said on Nov 21, 2010

Typo "Coment" in the photo of the bald head.

Joe Joe said on Dec 31, 2010

I agree on the article. It''s great. And many websites join the "let''s have a Facebook like button on our site", which is great I think. It does move towards more socialized browsing experiences.

One project I think does really well, is Snoost - Speaking of John Mayer :D

snoost.com/#!/John-Mayer/Inside-Wants-Out/Back-to-You/

Coach Purses said on Apr 27, 2012

You guys have a wonderful website intending the following, KIU!

Air Jordan said on May 21, 2012

This blog site is great. How did you come up witht he idea?

Marni Jewelry said on May 23, 2012

Intimately, the submit is definitely the very best on this precious topic. I concur with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward in your coming updates!