You are reading a MIX Online Opinion. In which we speak our minds.  Meet Arrow

Lab Notes

22Comment Retweet

YouTube using Silverlight

Mar 19, 2009 By

Go to Steve Clayton’s blog, the Geek in Disguise to get the details.

Follow the Conversation

22 comments so far. You should leave one, too.

M Sheik Uduman Ali said on Mar 19, 2009

Its great

Tom.S said on Mar 20, 2009

Whaat? If youtube really wants to shoot itself to leg, it can do this..

As long Silverlight is propietar technology what is controlled by Microsoft, it is not anyway better than Adobe Flash.

C''mon. Microsoft makes sure that newest version is always for Windows NT only. They leave off other OS''s like Darwin or Linux. Currently for Linux there is 1.0 released, what is far behind from newest 2.0 version.

In real life, you can not use at all those sites what uses silverlight because they are 2.0 version.

If Microsoft would open source the silverlight and actually develop it for all OS''s, (NT, Darwin, Linux etc) it would be nice to have.

Joshua Allen said on Mar 20, 2009

@Tom: Silverlight *is* available for Mac and Linux. I have no idea where you got the idea that Silverlight is for "Windows NT only", but that is false and you shouldn''t be repeating it.

Pradeep said on Mar 20, 2009

Youtube is now owned by Google and highly unlikely that impossible that it will shake hands with silverlight!.

Ben Hayat said on Mar 20, 2009

@Tom: You need to wake up and smell the coffee! ;-)

John Graham said on Mar 20, 2009

Maybe they shoot themselves in the leg if they would stick to Flash.

Uma said on Mar 20, 2009

Flash players suck in slow connections! It''s a smart move for Youtube. Silverlight truely lights up the web.

Dennis said on Mar 20, 2009

My major SilverLight gripe is that it''s not available as a .msi

Flash is a tidy .msi and a text file to control it''s behavior. It''s been a treat to deploy in the enterprise for years.

Voytek said on Mar 21, 2009

I am a little bit confused. Is Flash an open source?

Amour Rashid said on Mar 21, 2009

They said .net would not succeed what do they say today.
They said the same about silverlight. But everyone can witness it has achieved in a very short period. What will they say tomorrow?

Ashish Jha said on Mar 21, 2009

Nice to read so much info about silverlight. Til now i was reluctant to use silverlight myself but after reading this conversation, i installed it.
:)

teen7 said on Mar 22, 2009

what is silverlight and how is it useful for a common student and a developer can any one plz say me

Chris said on Mar 22, 2009

Google is actually pretty Microsoft oriented... They have a plethora of .Net based projects out there. I would be surprised if they have not considered using silverlight for major development.

AlfeG said on Mar 23, 2009

>>Tom.S said
>>>As long Silverlight is propietar technology what is controlled by Microsoft, it is not anyway better than Adobe Flash.

Adobe is MUCH MUCH more propriate than silverlight

Joe said on Mar 24, 2009

I think is great. Silverlight has great possibilities, and Microsoft has worked really hard to achieve that level of user experience, keep it up Silverlight team, congrats!

Cipper Tech said on Mar 24, 2009

it would be really cool if YouTube uses Silverilght!

Mikko said on Aug 11, 2009

@Joshua Allen

no there''s no silverlight for linux dists!

Joshua Allen said on Aug 11, 2009

@Mikko - The Silverlight version for Linux distros is called "Moonlight", and is built by the guys behind the mono project, with some assistance from Microsoft.

Mikko said on Aug 11, 2009

it doesn''t support silverlight 3 and drm + more and it''s locked out of Feynman lectures

Joshua Allen said on Aug 11, 2009

@Mikko -- You''re right. With Gestalt, we stuck to Silverlight 2 so that we could support Linux, and the majority of content out there is SL2, but some sites took dependencies on SL3 functionality that won''t be on Linux for awhile.

Paul Huff said on Nov 19, 2009

Silverlight is awesome. I''m curious how they are planning on using Silverlight...seems it would be a poor ROI business decision with everything already working on FLash (unless the underlying videos are H.265 which SL now supports).

My gripe is that Silverlight is SOO far behind on Linux. Thats where Flash creams them. For me, I would LOVE to create Silverlight 3 applications to be interfaces on HMI devices (human machine interface....touch panels running embedded systems). That would really help my quest for world domination!

Marc Roussel said on Sep 24, 2010

Just two word. Silverlight please.

Youtube web site lack the user experience. The video quality which is nothing compared to Silverlight is poor and the video browsing, aaaah man.

It would be so much interesting to browse YouTube videos with Silverlight nice UI and great video quality.

I''m sure YouTube would gain a lot of observers just because of that and by the same way would make advertisements way much interesting for people advertising as well as those who look at them.

We'll use your email to grab your gravatar. We won't store your email or sell it to trolls.